Affaan MustafaTrading lead at Jump Trading; ECC 290k+ stars3,400 installs on skills.shScholar Evaluation
Structured scholarly-work evaluation for papers.
Use Edge to load the skill scholar-evaluation from affaan-m/ecc for my task. If Edge is not set up, read getedge.cc/SKILL.md and ask me first.
2 static scans, 0 counted findings.
Edge checks it again each time your agent loads it.
What it does
Structured scholarly-work evaluation for papers, proposals, literature reviews, methods sections, evidence quality, citation support, and research-writing feedback. Use when evaluating academic or scientific work : papers, proposals, methods sections, or evidence quality : against a repeatable rubric.
Why Affaan Mustafa
Compute Trading Lead at Jump Trading. Each fact links its public source.
- Role at Jump Trading
His GitHub bio says Compute Trading Lead at Jump Trading, previously founding The Agentic Desk.
GitHub profile - Hugely starred agent harness repo
ECC has 290k+ GitHub stars.
GitHub repo - Security tool with traction
agentshield has 1.3k+ GitHub stars.
GitHub repo
How it works
- 1Copy
Try for free gives you one prompt.
- 2Paste
Paste it into Claude Code, Codex or Cursor.
- 3Ask
Ask for the outcome. Your agent loads Scholar Evaluation.
Related skills
Search and analyze academic literature. Find papers, understand research methodologies, and synthesize academic findings for research projects.
Compose, revise, or audit research proposals, opening reports, and research plans from supporting evidence. Use for 研究计划、开题报告、科研项目申请书. Invoked as researchwrite for compatibility; use nature-writing for general manuscript
Systematic literature-review workflow for academic, biomedical, technical, and scientific topics, including search planning, source screening, synthesis, citation checks, and evidence logging. Use when the task is to fin
Search academic papers via OpenAlex API for open citation data, institutional affiliations, and funding information. Use when user says "openalex search", "search openalex", "open citation graph", or wants comprehensive
Search research papers via Gemini for broad literature discovery. Use when user says "gemini search", "gemini papers", "search with gemini", or wants AI-powered literature discovery beyond arXiv/Semantic Scholar indexes.
Research a topic in depth using web search, academic papers, and citation graphs. Use when the user asks to research, investigate, or explore a topic thoroughly.
No evidence record yet
No measured run with and without this skill yet, so this page makes no performance claim. 2 static scans, 0 counted findings. Security state at 2026-11-17: reviewed. Static scans check the code, not how well the skill works.
State definitionsSelect the Files tab to load SKILL.md.
Skill details
Security scansReviewed
2 static scans, 0 counted findings. Security state at 2026-11-17: reviewed. Edge checks it again each time your agent loads it.
Edge static checks (Edge-run): edge-static/1.0.2. Scope: Static patterns for remote execution, credentials with network sends, obfuscation, prompt overrides, hidden Unicode, binaries and persistence. Raw findings: not supplied.
Edge committed-secret checks (Edge-run): edge-secrets/1.0.0. Scope: Credentials committed in the skill's files (values never shown). Raw findings: not supplied.
Socket (skills.sh mirror): Version unavailable. Scope: Not supplied by the mirrored record. Raw findings: not supplied.
Snyk (skills.sh mirror): Version unavailable. Scope: Not supplied by the mirrored record. Raw findings: not supplied.
- Edge static checks
- Pass · 0 counted findings · 2026-11-17
- Edge committed-secret checks
- Pass · 0 counted findings · 2026-11-17
Creator, source & licenceaffaan-m
From the affaan-m public repository. Edge did not write or edit this skill.
- Repository
- affaan-m/ecc
- Skill file
- View source at revision
- Revision
- d3b8a3e908904e242ed2dbe66af62cca71131419
- Package hash
- sha256:b550d3bca00c54ff5c4856c5164fb422d6f238312299900d237c266125234d9d
- Licence
- MIT
- Description
- Structured scholarly-work evaluation for papers, proposals, literature reviews, methods sections, evidence quality, citation support, and research-writing feedback. Use when evaluating academic or scientific work : papers, proposals, methods sections, or evidence quality : against a repeatable rubric.
Quoted from the skill’s own description
Read skill files1 file
1 file, 4.8 KB at revision d3b8a3e90890.
Questions about Scholar Evaluation
What does Scholar Evaluation do?
Structured scholarly-work evaluation for papers. Published by Affaan Mustafa (affaan-m/ecc).
Is Scholar Evaluation safe to use?
Edge security state: Reviewed (2 Edge-run static scans, scanned Nov 17, 2026). The Evidence tab shows the scan.
How do I use Scholar Evaluation in Claude Code, Codex or Cursor?
Click Try for free, pick your agent and follow its one step. Edge is free, with no Edge account.
Similar skills

Rigor Analyze / Rigor Audit read-only skill for deep learning research repositories. Use when the user wants to read and understand a reposi…

When the user wants to apply psychology to marketing, or asks why buyers behave or value things as they do, or whether a persuasion tactic i…

Comprehensive product research and opportunity analysis for Amazon sellers. Analyzes demand, competition, profit potential, market entry bar…

Produce an intensive, cited analytical report: executive summary, multi-angle findings, contrarian views, open questions, and full sources.…

Estimates TAM, SAM, and SOM for a market or sub-segment to ground sales capacity, territory, and quota planning - top-down, bottom-up on nam…

Organize research — manage references, notes, and collaboration.

Research a topic in depth with Tavily. Use this skill when a question needs many sources gathered and weighed together: analysing a market,…

Apply STRIDE methodology to systematically identify threats. Use when analyzing system security, conducting threat modeling sessions, or cre…