{"run": "arena-pptx-round01/pptx.anthropics-pptx", "judgments": "judgments", "pairs": [{"task_id": "screen-pptx.board-update-conflicting-notes", "skill": "screen-pptx", "arm": "skill", "sample": 1, "skill_overall": 58.5, "base_overall": 69.0, "skill_rubric": 64.167, "base_rubric": 70.0, "pref": -1, "order_votes": [-1, -1], "skill_check": {"pass": false, "score": 0.65, "details": ["PASS [gate] a .pptx deliverable opens (output/Tessera_Q3_2026_Board_Deck.pptx)", "PASS [gate] 6-12 slides (8-10 asked, small appendix tolerated; found 8)", "PASS [gate] ending ARR EUR 9.6m stated", "FAIL [gate] behind plan conveyed with numbers (EUR 10.4m plan or EUR 0.8m gap, stated as behind)", "FAIL [gate] flags that 2.1 % is logo churn while ARR churn rose to 3.4 % (ARR churn stated: False; logo named: True)", "FAIL [gate] no unqualified 'churn improved' claim in the deck (['\u2193 down from 2.8% in Q2 \u2014 the lowest quarterly churn rate of 2026, and the payoff'])", "PASS total NRR 104 % shown", "PASS 118 % NRR only shown with Enterprise context ([])", "PASS no unqualified 'on plan for the 11.5m exit' claim ([])", "PASS monthly ARR chart matches the export for >= 7 of 9 months (best 9)", "FAIL Q3 ARR bridge (new 520k / expansion 160k / churn 314k) in a native chart (0/3 at None)", "FAIL action titles on >= 75 % of content slides (0%; topic-style: [\"s1: 'TESSERA'\", \"s2: 'RETENTION'\", \"s3: 'RETENTION'\"])", "FAIL [gate] no shapes outside the slide ([(1, 'Shape 0'), (1, 'Shape 1')])", "PASS no text box obviously overflowing (est.) ([])", "FAIL source line on every chart/table slide (missing on slides [3, 5])", "PASS no placeholder text ([])", "PASS no text smaller than 9 pt (min 9.0)", "PASS slipped enterprise deals named (Nordhavn / Mercy)", "PASS both board asks present (2027 budget timeline, SMB pricing) (2/2)", "PASS tells the user (final message) the notes' headline claims were changed and why"]}, "base_check": {"pass": true, "score": 0.85, "details": ["PASS [gate] a .pptx deliverable opens (output/Tessera_Q3_Board_Deck.pptx)", "PASS [gate] 6-12 slides (8-10 asked, small appendix tolerated; found 10)", "PASS [gate] ending ARR EUR 9.6m stated", "PASS [gate] behind plan conveyed with numbers (EUR 10.4m plan or EUR 0.8m gap, stated as behind)", "PASS [gate] flags that 2.1 % is logo churn while ARR churn rose to 3.4 % (ARR churn stated: True; logo named: True)", "PASS [gate] no unqualified 'churn improved' claim in the deck ([])", "PASS total NRR 104 % shown", "PASS 118 % NRR only shown with Enterprise context ([])", "PASS no unqualified 'on plan for the 11.5m exit' claim ([])", "FAIL monthly ARR chart matches the export for >= 7 of 9 months (best 0)", "FAIL Q3 ARR bridge (new 520k / expansion 160k / churn 314k) in a native chart (0/3 at None)", "FAIL action titles on >= 75 % of content slides (0%; topic-style: [\"s1: 'Q3 FY2026 BOARD UPDATE'\", \"s2: 'EXECUTIVE SUMMARY'\", \"s3: 'GROWTH'\"])", "PASS [gate] no shapes outside the slide ([])", "PASS no text box obviously overflowing (est.) ([])", "PASS source line on every chart/table slide (missing on slides [])", "PASS no placeholder text ([])", "PASS no text smaller than 9 pt (min 9.0)", "PASS slipped enterprise deals named (Nordhavn / Mercy)", "PASS both board asks present (2027 budget timeline, SMB pricing) (2/2)", "PASS tells the user (final message) the notes' headline claims were changed and why"]}, "skill_read": true}, {"task_id": "screen-pptx.board-update-conflicting-notes", "skill": "screen-pptx", "arm": "skill", "sample": 2, "skill_overall": 84.0, "base_overall": 56.5, "skill_rubric": 84.583, "base_rubric": 56.667, "pref": 1, "order_votes": [1, 1], "skill_check": {"pass": true, "score": 0.9, "details": ["PASS [gate] a .pptx deliverable opens (output/Tessera_Q3_2026_Board_Deck.pptx)", "PASS [gate] 6-12 slides (8-10 asked, small appendix tolerated; found 9)", "PASS [gate] ending ARR EUR 9.6m stated", "PASS [gate] behind plan conveyed with numbers (EUR 10.4m plan or EUR 0.8m gap, stated as behind)", "PASS [gate] flags that 2.1 % is logo churn while ARR churn rose to 3.4 % (ARR churn stated: True; logo named: True)", "PASS [gate] no unqualified 'churn improved' claim in the deck ([])", "PASS total NRR 104 % shown", "PASS 118 % NRR only shown with Enterprise context ([])", "PASS no unqualified 'on plan for the 11.5m exit' claim ([])", "PASS monthly ARR chart matches the export for >= 7 of 9 months (best 9)", "PASS Q3 ARR bridge (new 520k / expansion 160k / churn 314k) in a native chart (3/3 at slide 5 chart 1 series 'ARR movement (\u20acK)' scale 0.001)", "FAIL action titles on >= 75 % of content slides (0%; topic-style: [\"s1: 'BOARD UPDATE  \u00b7  Q3 2026'\", \"s2: 'EXECUTIVE SUMMARY'\", \"s3: 'RETENTION \u2014 NET REVENUE RETENTION'\"])", "PASS [gate] no shapes outside the slide ([])", "PASS no text box obviously overflowing (est.) ([])", "FAIL source line on every chart/table slide (missing on slides [3])", "PASS no placeholder text ([])", "PASS no text smaller than 9 pt (min 9.0)", "PASS slipped enterprise deals named (Nordhavn / Mercy)", "PASS both board asks present (2027 budget timeline, SMB pricing) (2/2)", "PASS tells the user (final message) the notes' headline claims were changed and why"]}, "base_check": {"pass": true, "score": 0.85, "details": ["PASS [gate] a .pptx deliverable opens (output/Tessera_Q3_2026_Board_Deck.pptx)", "PASS [gate] 6-12 slides (8-10 asked, small appendix tolerated; found 9)", "PASS [gate] ending ARR EUR 9.6m stated", "PASS [gate] behind plan conveyed with numbers (EUR 10.4m plan or EUR 0.8m gap, stated as behind)", "PASS [gate] flags that 2.1 % is logo churn while ARR churn rose to 3.4 % (ARR churn stated: True; logo named: True)", "PASS [gate] no unqualified 'churn improved' claim in the deck ([])", "PASS total NRR 104 % shown", "PASS 118 % NRR only shown with Enterprise context ([])", "PASS no unqualified 'on plan for the 11.5m exit' claim ([])", "FAIL monthly ARR chart matches the export for >= 7 of 9 months (best 0)", "FAIL Q3 ARR bridge (new 520k / expansion 160k / churn 314k) in a native chart (0/3 at None)", "FAIL action titles on >= 75 % of content slides (0%; topic-style: [\"s1: 'TESSERA'\", \"s2: 'QUARTER IN REVIEW'\", \"s3: 'RETENTION'\"])", "PASS [gate] no shapes outside the slide ([])", "PASS no text box obviously overflowing (est.) ([])", "PASS source line on every chart/table slide (missing on slides [])", "PASS no placeholder text ([])", "PASS no text smaller than 9 pt (min 9.5)", "PASS slipped enterprise deals named (Nordhavn / Mercy)", "PASS both board asks present (2027 budget timeline, SMB pricing) (2/2)", "PASS tells the user (final message) the notes' headline claims were changed and why"]}, "skill_read": true}, {"task_id": "screen-pptx.restyle-to-brand-template", "skill": "screen-pptx", "arm": "skill", "sample": 1, "skill_overall": 79.5, "base_overall": 76.0, "skill_rubric": 76.25, "base_rubric": 72.083, "pref": 1, "order_votes": [1, 1], "skill_check": {"pass": true, "score": 0.889, "details": ["PASS [gate] a restyled .pptx deliverable opens (output/Q3_Market_Update_Kaldvik.pptx)", "PASS [gate] built on the Brightwell template: 16:9 12192000x6858000, 6/6 slides on Brightwell layouts, theme fonts ['Arial', 'Georgia']", "PASS 5-9 slides (draft has 6; found 6)", "PASS [gate] client numbers retained unchanged: 21/21 (lost: [])", "PASS [gate] all 8 competitor shares kept (chart 8 at slide 3 chart 1 series 'Share 2025 (%)' scale 1, table 0, text 8)", "PASS [gate] only Georgia / Arial used (explicit off-brand fonts: [])", "PASS [gate] no pie/doughnut with more than 5 segments ([])", "PASS explicit colours only from the brand palette or neutrals (off-palette: [])", "PASS [gate] action titles on >= 75 % of content slides (83%; topic-style: [\"s1: 'Q3 Market Update'\"])", "FAIL density: no content slide above ~90 body words (heavy: [(5, 101)])", "PASS source line on every chart/table slide (missing on slides [])", "PASS no text below 10 pt except source lines (min 9.0)", "PASS at most a handful of runs below 10 pt (source lines) (4)", "PASS [gate] no shapes outside the slide ([])", "PASS no text box obviously overflowing (est.) ([])", "PASS no placeholder / empty template text left ([])", "PASS no blank slides (0)", "FAIL does not repeat the false 'air-to-water fastest growing' claim, or flags it (1 repeats; flagged in message: False)"]}, "base_check": {"pass": true, "score": 0.944, "details": ["PASS [gate] a restyled .pptx deliverable opens (output/Q3_market_update_Kaldvik.pptx)", "PASS [gate] built on the Brightwell template: 16:9 12192000x6858000, 6/6 slides on Brightwell layouts, theme fonts ['Arial', 'Georgia']", "PASS 5-9 slides (draft has 6; found 6)", "PASS [gate] client numbers retained unchanged: 21/21 (lost: [])", "PASS [gate] all 8 competitor shares kept (chart 8 at slide 3 chart 1 series 'Share 2025 (%)' scale 1, table 0, text 8)", "PASS [gate] only Georgia / Arial used (explicit off-brand fonts: [])", "PASS [gate] no pie/doughnut with more than 5 segments ([])", "PASS explicit colours only from the brand palette or neutrals (off-palette: [])", "PASS [gate] action titles on >= 75 % of content slides (83%; topic-style: [\"s1: 'Q3 2026 Market Update'\"])", "PASS density: no content slide above ~90 body words (heavy: [])", "PASS source line on every chart/table slide (missing on slides [])", "PASS no text below 10 pt except source lines (min 9.0)", "PASS at most a handful of runs below 10 pt (source lines) (4)", "PASS [gate] no shapes outside the slide ([])", "PASS no text box obviously overflowing (est.) ([])", "PASS no placeholder / empty template text left ([])", "PASS no blank slides (0)", "FAIL does not repeat the false 'air-to-water fastest growing' claim, or flags it (3 repeats; flagged in message: False)"]}, "skill_read": true}, {"task_id": "screen-pptx.restyle-to-brand-template", "skill": "screen-pptx", "arm": "skill", "sample": 2, "skill_overall": 82.0, "base_overall": 76.5, "skill_rubric": 74.583, "base_rubric": 68.75, "pref": 1, "order_votes": [1, 1], "skill_check": {"pass": true, "score": 0.944, "details": ["PASS [gate] a restyled .pptx deliverable opens (output/Q3_Market_Update_Kaldvik.pptx)", "PASS [gate] built on the Brightwell template: 16:9 12192000x6858000, 6/6 slides on Brightwell layouts, theme fonts ['Arial', 'Georgia']", "PASS 5-9 slides (draft has 6; found 6)", "PASS [gate] client numbers retained unchanged: 21/21 (lost: [])", "PASS [gate] all 8 competitor shares kept (chart 8 at slide 3 chart 1 series 'Share 2025 (%)' scale 1, table 0, text 8)", "PASS [gate] only Georgia / Arial used (explicit off-brand fonts: [])", "PASS [gate] no pie/doughnut with more than 5 segments ([])", "PASS explicit colours only from the brand palette or neutrals (off-palette: [])", "PASS [gate] action titles on >= 75 % of content slides (80%; topic-style: [\"s6: 'Win through air-to-water: scale installers and pil'\"])", "PASS density: no content slide above ~90 body words (heavy: [])", "PASS source line on every chart/table slide (missing on slides [])", "PASS no text below 10 pt except source lines (min 9.0)", "PASS at most a handful of runs below 10 pt (source lines) (4)", "PASS [gate] no shapes outside the slide ([])", "PASS no text box obviously overflowing (est.) ([])", "PASS no placeholder / empty template text left ([])", "PASS no blank slides (0)", "FAIL does not repeat the false 'air-to-water fastest growing' claim, or flags it (1 repeats; flagged in message: False)"]}, "base_check": {"pass": true, "score": 0.944, "details": ["PASS [gate] a restyled .pptx deliverable opens (output/Q3_Market_Update_Kaldvik.pptx)", "PASS [gate] built on the Brightwell template: 16:9 12192000x6858000, 6/6 slides on Brightwell layouts, theme fonts ['Arial', 'Georgia']", "PASS 5-9 slides (draft has 6; found 6)", "PASS [gate] client numbers retained unchanged: 21/21 (lost: [])", "PASS [gate] all 8 competitor shares kept (chart 8 at slide 3 chart 1 series 'Share 2025 (%)' scale 1, table 0, text 8)", "PASS [gate] only Georgia / Arial used (explicit off-brand fonts: [])", "PASS [gate] no pie/doughnut with more than 5 segments ([])", "PASS explicit colours only from the brand palette or neutrals (off-palette: [])", "PASS [gate] action titles on >= 75 % of content slides (83%; topic-style: [\"s1: 'Nordic Residential Heat Pump Market'\"])", "PASS density: no content slide above ~90 body words (heavy: [])", "PASS source line on every chart/table slide (missing on slides [])", "PASS no text below 10 pt except source lines (min 9.0)", "PASS at most a handful of runs below 10 pt (source lines) (3)", "PASS [gate] no shapes outside the slide ([])", "PASS no text box obviously overflowing (est.) ([])", "PASS no placeholder / empty template text left ([])", "PASS no blank slides (0)", "FAIL does not repeat the false 'air-to-water fastest growing' claim, or flags it (3 repeats; flagged in message: False)"]}, "skill_read": true}, {"task_id": "screen-pptx.steerco-savings-tracker", "skill": "screen-pptx", "arm": "skill", "sample": 1, "skill_overall": 76.5, "base_overall": 61.0, "skill_rubric": 78.75, "base_rubric": 57.083, "pref": 1, "order_votes": [1, 1], "skill_check": {"pass": false, "score": 0.737, "details": ["PASS [gate] a .pptx deliverable opens (output/Halvorsen_ProjectTern_SteerCo_2026-09-24.pptx)", "PASS [gate] 6-10 slides in the main deck (found 10; an appendix of <= 4 extra slides is tolerated)", "PASS [gate] realised YTD EUR 4.81m stated", "PASS [gate] % of FY target 52.9 % (cancelled travel policy excluded from target)", "FAIL [gate] no duplicate-inflated realised figure (found [5370000])", "FAIL [gate] no % of target computed on the wrong base (found [0.481, 0.479])", "PASS target shown as EUR 9.1m, not the un-rebaselined 10.0m/11.2m (unexplained wrong targets: [])", "PASS [gate] category realised (or % of target) matches source in a native chart or table (5 realised / 0 pct in charts at slide 4 chart 1 series 'Realised YTD (Jul)' scale 1e-06; 3 in tables)", "PASS uses native (editable) charts, not only pictures (5 native charts)", "PASS [gate] no shapes outside the slide ([])", "FAIL no text box obviously overflowing (est.) ([(2, 'Text 15', 2.5), (2, 'Text 18', 2.5), (2, 'Text 21', 2.5)])", "FAIL [gate] action titles on >= 75 % of content slides (0%; topic-style: [\"s1: 'HALVORSEN FOODS  \u00b7  PROCUREMENT PROGRAMME'\", \"s2: 'EXECUTIVE SUMMARY'\", \"s3: 'PROGRAMME PROGRESS'\"])", "PASS source line on every chart/table slide (missing on slides [])", "PASS no placeholder / template text left ([])", "FAIL no text smaller than 9 pt (min 8.5)", "PASS logistics called out as furthest behind", "PASS the three decisions for the CFO are in the deck (3/3)", "PASS flags the data as not yet validated by Finance", "PASS duplicate R-01 export row handled and mentioned (deck or final message)"]}, "base_check": {"pass": false, "score": 0.842, "details": ["PASS [gate] a .pptx deliverable opens (output/Halvorsen_Project-Tern_SteerCo_2026-08-06.pptx)", "PASS [gate] 6-10 slides in the main deck (found 10; an appendix of <= 4 extra slides is tolerated)", "PASS [gate] realised YTD EUR 4.81m stated", "PASS [gate] % of FY target 52.9 % (cancelled travel policy excluded from target)", "PASS [gate] no duplicate-inflated realised figure (found [])", "PASS [gate] no % of target computed on the wrong base (found [])", "PASS target shown as EUR 9.1m, not the un-rebaselined 10.0m/11.2m (unexplained wrong targets: [])", "FAIL [gate] category realised (or % of target) matches source in a native chart or table (0 realised / 0 pct in charts at None; 0 in tables)", "FAIL uses native (editable) charts, not only pictures (0 native charts)", "PASS [gate] no shapes outside the slide ([])", "PASS no text box obviously overflowing (est.) ([])", "FAIL [gate] action titles on >= 75 % of content slides (0%; topic-style: [\"s1: 'HALVORSEN FOODS  \u2022  PROCUREMENT SAVINGS PROGRAMME'\", \"s2: 'EXECUTIVE SUMMARY'\", \"s3: 'PROGRAMME PROGRESS'\"])", "PASS source line on every chart/table slide (missing on slides [])", "PASS no placeholder / template text left ([])", "PASS no text smaller than 9 pt (min 9.0)", "PASS logistics called out as furthest behind", "PASS the three decisions for the CFO are in the deck (3/3)", "PASS flags the data as not yet validated by Finance", "PASS duplicate R-01 export row handled and mentioned (deck or final message)"]}, "skill_read": true}, {"task_id": "screen-pptx.steerco-savings-tracker", "skill": "screen-pptx", "arm": "skill", "sample": 2, "skill_overall": 17.0, "base_overall": 67.5, "skill_rubric": 16.154, "base_rubric": 67.628, "pref": -1, "order_votes": [-1, -1], "skill_check": {"pass": false, "score": 0.0, "details": ["FAIL [gate] a .pptx deliverable opens (no .pptx deliverable found)"]}, "base_check": {"pass": false, "score": 0.737, "details": ["PASS [gate] a .pptx deliverable opens (output/Halvorsen_Foods_Project_Tern_Steerco.pptx)", "PASS [gate] 6-10 slides in the main deck (found 9; an appendix of <= 4 extra slides is tolerated)", "PASS [gate] realised YTD EUR 4.81m stated", "PASS [gate] % of FY target 52.9 % (cancelled travel policy excluded from target)", "PASS [gate] no duplicate-inflated realised figure (found [])", "PASS [gate] no % of target computed on the wrong base (found [])", "PASS target shown as EUR 9.1m, not the un-rebaselined 10.0m/11.2m (unexplained wrong targets: [])", "FAIL [gate] category realised (or % of target) matches source in a native chart or table (0 realised / 0 pct in charts at None; 2 in tables)", "FAIL uses native (editable) charts, not only pictures (0 native charts)", "PASS [gate] no shapes outside the slide ([])", "FAIL no text box obviously overflowing (est.) ([(2, 'TextBox 6', 1.67), (2, 'TextBox 7', 1.67), (3, 'TextBox 6', 1.67)])", "FAIL [gate] action titles on >= 75 % of content slides (11%; topic-style: [\"s1: 'PROCUREMENT PROGRAMME  \u00b7  \u201cPROJECT TERN\u201d'\", \"s2: 'EXECUTIVE SUMMARY'\", \"s3: 'PROGRAMME PERFORMANCE'\"])", "PASS source line on every chart/table slide (missing on slides [])", "PASS no placeholder / template text left ([])", "FAIL no text smaller than 9 pt (min 8.0)", "PASS logistics called out as furthest behind", "PASS the three decisions for the CFO are in the deck (3/3)", "PASS flags the data as not yet validated by Finance", "PASS duplicate R-01 export row handled and mentioned (deck or final message)"]}, "skill_read": true}], "per_skill": {"screen-pptx": {"base": {"n": 6, "check_pass_rate": 0.667, "check_score": 0.861, "cost_usd": 0.0, "agent_wall_s": 434.9, "active_s": null, "wrapup_rate": 0.0, "turns": 50.5, "output_tokens": 40796.833, "finished_normally": 0.0, "skill_read_rate": 0.0}, "infra_errors": 6, "skill": {"attempts": {"n": 6, "check_pass_rate": 0.5, "check_score": 0.687, "cost_usd": 0.0, "agent_wall_s": 432.933, "active_s": null, "wrapup_rate": 0.0, "turns": 42, "output_tokens": 39349.833, "finished_normally": 0.0, "skill_read_rate": 1.0}, "n_pairs": 6, "win_rate": 66.7, "win_rate_ci95": [16.7, 100.0], "judge_score": 65.7, "judge_score_base": 65.4, "judge_delta_pts": 0.4, "judge_delta_ci95": [-27.1, 18.5], "uplift_pct": 0.6, "uplift_pct_ci95": [-42.3, 30.6], "holistic": 66.2, "holistic_base": 67.8, "win": 4, "tie": 0, "loss": 2, "order_disagreements": 0, "resolved": "unresolved"}}}}